Faculty

Social Science

Supervisor Name

Kaitlynn Mendes

Keywords

"Instagram vs reality" "body image" "content analysis" "thematic analysis" "media literacy" "body positivity"

Description

A couple of years ago, the “Instagram vs. reality” trend sprung from Instagram’s body positivity movement. The trend encourages Instagram users to post side-by-side images of themselves — one side being the highly curated “Instagram” depiction and the other being a more ‘real’ depiction. One study has explored the trend academically, and it found that engaging with “Instagram vs reality” and “reality” images decreased body dissatisfaction amongst its participants relative to viewing idealized “Instagram” images. In an effort to understand who is participating in the trend, what they are contributing to the trend, and why they are engaging with it, this study examined 150 images and their captions from #instagramvsreality on Instagram. Results demonstrated that the subjects participating in the trend are less diverse in appearance than those in the body positivity movement. Yet, many subjects spoke about how Instagram is ‘fake’ and that people ought to not compare themselves to the images they see online. While subjects often did engage with body positive messaging, the authors concluded that the Instagram vs reality trend may be more about promoting media literacy, and hence, that could explain why the trend contains less diversity in appearance than the body positivity movement, which aims to challenge the narrowly-defined standards that govern beauty and appearance.

(This is the lay output for the research project. The research paper will be available elsewhere or on this site at a later period.)

Creative Commons License

Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 4.0 License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 4.0 License

Document Type

Poster

Share

COinS
 

“A content and thematic analysis of #instagramvsreality images and captions on Instagram” (PowerPoint)

A couple of years ago, the “Instagram vs. reality” trend sprung from Instagram’s body positivity movement. The trend encourages Instagram users to post side-by-side images of themselves — one side being the highly curated “Instagram” depiction and the other being a more ‘real’ depiction. One study has explored the trend academically, and it found that engaging with “Instagram vs reality” and “reality” images decreased body dissatisfaction amongst its participants relative to viewing idealized “Instagram” images. In an effort to understand who is participating in the trend, what they are contributing to the trend, and why they are engaging with it, this study examined 150 images and their captions from #instagramvsreality on Instagram. Results demonstrated that the subjects participating in the trend are less diverse in appearance than those in the body positivity movement. Yet, many subjects spoke about how Instagram is ‘fake’ and that people ought to not compare themselves to the images they see online. While subjects often did engage with body positive messaging, the authors concluded that the Instagram vs reality trend may be more about promoting media literacy, and hence, that could explain why the trend contains less diversity in appearance than the body positivity movement, which aims to challenge the narrowly-defined standards that govern beauty and appearance.

(This is the lay output for the research project. The research paper will be available elsewhere or on this site at a later period.)

 

To view the content in your browser, please download Adobe Reader or, alternately,
you may Download the file to your hard drive.

NOTE: The latest versions of Adobe Reader do not support viewing PDF files within Firefox on Mac OS and if you are using a modern (Intel) Mac, there is no official plugin for viewing PDF files within the browser window.