Electronic Thesis and Dissertation Repository

Thesis Format

Monograph

Degree

Doctor of Philosophy

Program

Comparative Literature

Supervisor

Lee, Alison.

2nd Supervisor

Sajid, Nida.

Affiliation

University of Minnesota

Co-Supervisor

Abstract

This thesis discusses the politics of the female body in memoirs and fictional works written by Middle Eastern refugee women in Canada and the United States. These works include two memoirs: Breaking the Ocean by Annahid Dashtgerd and We Have Always Been Here by Samra Habib and two novels: A Teaspoon of Earth and Sea by Dina Nayeri and A Map of Home by Randa Jarrar. It addresses the research problem of how these women negotiate their identities, agency, and experiences of displacement/resettlement through their corporeal existence. The analysis is guided by the theoretical frameworks introduced under feminism including Elizabeth Grosz’s deconstruction of the mind/body binary, psychoanalytic feminism, intersectional feminism, and queer feminism which provides a lens to explore the unique narrative structures and thematic motifs inherent in memoir and fiction. Findings reveal a multi-dimensional exploration of the female body as a locus of cultural, societal, and political contestation. Central themes include the continuity of displacement in both the country of origin and the country of settlement, the dismantling of the white savior narrative and victimhood archetype, and the pursuit of bodily emancipation within and outside the female form in the specific context of Middle Eastern culture and history. The concept of continuity of displacement in the case of Middle Eastern refugee women illuminates how displacement permeates various aspects of their lives, transcending geographical borders to encompass a profound sense of estrangement and displacement within cultural, historical, and societal contexts. Also, the thesis uncovers the complexities of cultural displacement, illustrating how the female body serves as both a vessel and battleground within shifting landscapes of tradition and modernity. It examines how societal norms and expectations shape the embodied experiences of Middle Eastern refugee women, leading to a nuanced understanding of their struggles and resilience. In addressing the white savior narrative and victimhood archetype, the study reveals how these narratives perpetuate oppressive structures, highlighting the agency and resilience of female refugees. It emphasizes the need to move beyond dichotomous portrayals of victimhood and explore the nuanced ways in which these women navigate societal constraints.

Summary for Lay Audience

This thesis discusses the complex relationship between Middle Eastern refugee women, their narratives, and the politics surrounding their bodies within the context of memoirs and fiction. Through an analysis of specific writings, including memoirs Breaking the Ocean and We Have Always Been Here, and novels A Teaspoon of Earth and Sea and A Map of Home, the research aims to unravel how these women negotiate their identities, agency, and the complexities of displacement and resettlement through the portrayal of their corporeal existence. Drawing from feminist theories such as Elizabeth Grosz's deconstruction of the mind/body binary, psychoanalytic feminism, intersectional feminism, and queer feminism, the analysis provides a lens to analyze the various narrative structures and thematic motifs inherent in the memoirs and fiction. Through this theoretical framework, the study uncovers a multifaceted exploration of the female body as a site of cultural, societal, and political contestation.

Central to the findings is the concept of the continuity of displacement, which sheds light on how displacement extends beyond mere geographical relocation. It illustrates how these women grapple with a profound sense of estrangement and displacement within cultural, historical, and societal contexts, transcending borders to encompass a complex web of experiences. Furthermore, the thesis discusses the complexities of cultural displacement, highlighting how societal norms and expectations shape the embodied experiences of Middle Eastern refugee women. By examining how these women navigate societal constraints, the study offers insights into their struggles and resilience. Another critical aspect of the research involves addressing the pervasive white savior narrative and victimhood archetype. By unpacking these narratives, the study reveals how these narratives perpetuate oppressive structures while emphasizing the agency and resilience of female refugees.

Available for download on Sunday, August 30, 2026

Share

COinS