Doctor of Philosophy
Wren, Jungsook C.
Canada’s plan for the permanent disposal of spent nuclear fuel involves a multiple-barrier system contained within a deep geologic repository (DGR). The key engineered barrier is the used fuel container (UFC), which is a copper-coated carbon steel vessel. The environments to which the copper coating will be exposed in the DGR are very different from those commonly encountered in copper corrosion studies. The copper (Cu) will be in contact with thin stagnant layers of water, and the corrosion system will be exposed to a continuous flux of γ-radiation. In the presence of γ-radiation, water and humid air decompose to redox-active species such as H2O2 andHNO3, which make the corrosion system more complex. Therefore, predicting the corrosion rate of Cu in the DGR and over long timescales is challenging.
Corrosion involves many electrochemical and chemical reactions that are coupled with interfacial transfer and solution transport of metal cations. The initial soluble corrosion products will accumulate with time, and the reactions and transport of the initial and intermediate corrosion products will provide routes for developing strong systemic feedback, which can induce autocatalytic reaction cycles. Hence, the overall corrosion rate is not expected to have a simple dependence on solution parameters, as would be predicted using linear chemical dynamics. This makes it difficult to apply existing corrosion models to predict the corrosion rate of copper in the environments anticipated in the DGR. Consequently, in order to develop a corrosion model that can be used to predict the long-term integrity of the UFC with confidence, it is critical to identify and decouple the key elementary processes controlling the overall rate.
In this thesis, systematic studies were conducted to decouple the effects of solution parameters on the Cu corrosion dynamics. The parameters investigated were pH, oxidant concentration, type of anion (e.g., SO42- and NO3-), and solution layer thickness (dsol), in the presence and absence of γ-radiation. A combination of coupon exposure tests and electrochemical measurements, along with post-test analyses, were performed to extract the rate parameters required for a predictive model. In this work, the bulk solution properties (dissolved copper and pH change) and the average chemical behaviour in the interfacial region (morphology/composition of the corroded surface) were simultaneously measured in order to investigate the copper corrosion dynamics.
This work has demonstrated that Cu corrosion progresses through different dynamic stages, and the key rate-determining steps have been identified for each stage. Stage 1 involves the oxidation of Cu0(m) (bound to the bulk metal) to solvated Cu2+(solv) in the interfacial region, followed by transport of Cu2+(solv) from the interfacial region to the bulk solution. When the bulk concentration of Cu2+(solv) approaches the solubility limit of Cu(OH)2, transport of Cu2+(solv) is significantly impeded, and hydrolysis occurs, accelerating the formation and precipitation of a Cu(OH)2 hydrogel. In Stage 2, the reduction of CuII species (Cu2+(solv) and Cu(OH)2) to CuI species (Cu+(solv) and Cu(OH)) in the hydrogel can be coupled with the oxidation of Cu0. The CuI species thus produced in the hydrogel layer then precipitate and grow as Cu2O crystals. Cuprous oxide crystal growth occurs via a redox-assisted Ostwald ripening process via coupling of the redox reactions of the redox active species (H2O2 and NO3-/NO2- redox pair) with the Cu0, CuI and CuII species. In Stage 3, the growth of thermodynamically more stable cupric-hydroxide-anion (CuII-OH-X) salt crystals occurs at the expense of Cu2O crystals.
The corrosion mechanism proposed in this thesis can successfully explain the effect of solution parameters on the overall corrosion rate. The solution parameters affect the rates of progression through the individual stages and the overall corrosion rates within the individual stages. From these time-dependent studies, the metal oxidation rate parameters required for model development can be extracted. This study is a step towards developing a high-fidelity corrosion model.
Summary for Lay Audience
Canada is exploring the long-term disposal of used nuclear fuel in a deep geologic repository (DGR) using a multiple-barrier system, with a key barrier being the used fuel container (UFC). Copper is an important candidate material for corrosion protection of the UFC. In the DGR, the copper surface will be in contact with small water volumes trapped in the clay buffer. The UFC and its environment will also be exposed to a continuous flux of γ-radiation.
To develop a copper corrosion model that can be used to predict the long-term integrity of the UFC with confidence, the effects of solution parameters on the copper corrosion dynamics in the presence and absence of γ-radiation were studied. The corrosion of copper metal in contact with a limited water volume was investigated as a function of corrosion time in different conditions by measuring the solution pH and dissolved copper, and analyzing the corroded coupon using different surface analysis techniques.
A mechanism for copper corrosion is proposed that can explain the effect of solution parameters on the overall corrosion rate. The key elementary processes that control the overall corrosion rate and the corrosion kinetics as a function of solution parameters are described. This study demonstrates that in a small stagnant water volume, the concentration of metal cations released due to corrosion can be high, even for a corrosion-resistant material like Cu. The solution reactions and transport of dissolved metal cations occur at rates that can strongly couple with electrochemical metal oxidation and precipitation of oxide deposits. In the presence of such strong systemic feedback, the effects of different solution parameters on the overall corrosion rate cannot be evaluated based on linear chemical dynamics.
This study is a step towards developing a high-fidelity copper corrosion model. The effect of γ-radiation on Cu corrosion can be modelled effectively by incorporating the net production rates of the key radiolysis products into the corrosion model based on the proposed mechanism. This thesis presents the key findings, their implications for corrosion science in general, and the potential implications of these results for the prediction of the UFC copper corrosion allowance.
Naghizadeh, Masoumeh, "Copper Corrosion Dynamics under Deep Geologic Repository Conditions" (2021). Electronic Thesis and Dissertation Repository. 7894.